Hello fellow Book Worms! I have re-discovered my library card! This means that my posts can't be definitive anymore because I don't know when I'll have time to peruse the library selection and get more, or if I'll settle for one of the 200 books I own that I've yet to read. :p Anyway, this is the first book that I have checked out of the library and will be reviewing.
Title: Sherlock Holmes vs. Dracula
Author: Loren D. Estleman
Series: Sherlock Holmes
Review:
I grew up reading Sherlock Holmes. I could recite most, if not all, of the Speckled Band. It wasn't until the 7th or 8th grade when I first picked up a vampire book and had read Dracula three times before the 9th grade. Sir Arthur Conan Doyle and Bram Stoker were literary geniuses. They have created two legendary figures and two masterpieces in literature. You can not believe my excitement when I saw the title of this book.
However, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle and Bram Stoker did NOT write this book. They had no input whatsoever. By the second or third chapter, I was relieved that I had only rented this book and not bought it.
Many have tried to touch the great Sherlock Holmes but I've only seen one succeed in Doyle's detective. That person is not Loren D. Estleman. Holmes' deductions were laughable and obvious and a few were so bizarre that even Holmes could not have reached such a conclusion. The logical man that is one of my favorite detectives jumped straight to supernatural without any other theories which I do not find believable.
Perhaps I'm so harsh with this book because I'm so familiar with Bram Stoker's novel, but I tired of this one really quickly. I mean, I've read Dracula so much that I know about 3 pages ahead what's about to happen. I don't know why I thought that this would be any different. I mean, part of the genius of Dracula was that Stoker wrote it through journals and letters so you heard about the vampire through others interpretations. Estleman chose straightforward narration. This would work if they hadn't had Dracula come in and then try to BRIBE Holmes and Watson. That's when I lost all hope for this novel.
So, I would not suggest this book to die-hard fans of either Sherlock Holmes or Dracula...however, if you are just starting out into the realms of either...then sure, pick up this book and ENJOY it. People like me that are all too familiar will not like it...at all. :p
Rating: 3.5
Future posts:
True Grit
Club Dead
Faithless (Maybe...depends on library-status :p)
Like it? Hate it? Read it yourself and wanna share your thoughts? Leave a comment!



